Our relationship has hit a few speed bumps lately (I blame Bill Hodges, the dull as dishwater depressed detective), but there's no denying that Stephen King is speaking to me when he addresses his "Constant reader." I've spent twenty years (!) reading his work. If you want to get *serious* about King I definitely recommend The Dark Tower, The Stand, and IT. But that's a lot of fucking pages filled with a lot of weird-ass shit to commit to. Luckily, King is also an O.Henry certified master of the short story game. So if you're interested in a quickie, here's where I'd start. Each story is ranked on a scariness scale of 1 to 5 Pennywises.
5. Beachworld (1985, collected in Skeleton Crew)
What could be so terrifying about sand? Turns out: a lot. This dark science-fiction story set in the far future takes the "sand gets everywhere!" nuisance known to beach-goers everywhere to a disturbing conclusion. I wish King would write more spacey stuff; especially in short story form. Tommyknockers and Dreamcatcher weren't his most coherent novels but
Scariness level: 2 Pennywises. This story is super creepy but also, just stay away from sand. Maybe it's a level 3 if you live by the beach.
4. I am the Doorway (1971, collected in Night Shift)
Hey look at that, more spacey stuff! I likes what I likes, I guess. This is the story of a wheelchair-bound ex-astronaut who came home with some unwelcome souvenirs after a fly-by of Venus. Because it's King, it's a bit more gross-out than your typical body invasion story. Which is of course a good thing. It's also a good example of the ambiguously ominous endings he's quite fond of. Classic ominiguous King.
3 Pennywises. Sure, you might not be going to Venus any time soon, but the squickyness of unwelcome body hitchhikers can't be rationally reasoned away.
3. The House on Maple Street (2009, collected in Nightmares and Dreamscapes)
King is one of the few writers, in my opinion, who can beautifully capture the feeling of being a kid. Of feeling small but also sure of what's right in the world, of feeling powerless but still believing in a sense of magic. In this tale, he follows the four Burdick children who come home from vacation to a subtly changing house. Machinery is growing behind the wallpaper, and a panel appears counting down to...something. Instead of calling Angie's List to find a contractor, as an adult might do, the kids see it as an opportunity to make some overdue changes to their family situation. Hi-jinks! Also, this story was inspired by a Chris Van Allsburg picture, which is rad.
1 Pennywise. There's suspense, but nothing too freaky-deaky. Relatively...
2. Mrs. Todd's Shortcut (1984, collected in Skeleton Crew)
I want to be Mrs. Todd. In her cute roadster, the wind in her hair, finding shortcuts that shouldn't exist. Parallel universes and all. King has definitely written a few problematic/eye-roll worthy women in his time, but Mrs. Todd is proof that he can write subtle, layered female characters. He frequently uses them to address themes of freedom and independence. Love interests aren't his strong suit but when his women stand alone, they often shine. Hmm, is there a life lesson in there? 🤔
1 Pennywise. Not really scary unless you get anxious just thinking about going off-road. Buckle up!
1. A Good Marriage (2010, collected in Full Dark, No Stars)
Speaking of female characters...so much of King's best writing has nothing to do with the supernatural. The world is pretty dark without ghosts, anyway. In this harrowing, inspired-by-real-events-tale, a suburban housewife has to confront her husband's secret. And we're not talking like, an Ashley Madison account, basic mid-life crisis-type level betrayal. This was made into a mediocre movie; which was predictable because it's such an internal story, told through Darcy's point-of-view as her world is flipped upside-down. It invites the reader to grapple and plot alongside her: What would you do? How would you do it? And, most difficult to answer, I think: would you go back, to before, if you could?
5 Pennywises! Real-life is always the scariest shit, that's why we have to read about supernatural killer clowns to get away from it all.